Impact-Resistant Shingles & Texas Insurance: A Celina Homeowner Guide

An educational look at Class 4 shingles for Celina, Melissa, Anna, Princeton, and Prosper homes. Not insurance or legal advice. Discounts and rules vary by carrier and policy, so confirm with your agent.

Hail is part of life in Celina and the wider Collin County growth corridor. That is why impact-resistant asphalt shingles come up in so many replacement conversations from Prosper to Princeton. Homeowners often hear two promises at once: "these hold up to hail better" and "your insurance will discount your premium." Both statements need nuance.

This guide pulls together what the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS), independent hail testing, Texas law, and NOAA storm records say about impact-resistant roofs. Sources are linked in the text and listed at the bottom. Rules and ratings change, so check the linked page before you rely on one.

The short version

  • "Class 4" is the top class in UL 2218, a lab test using a 2-inch steel ball. It measures cracking, not cosmetic dents.
  • Celina has had bigger hail than the test ball: NOAA reports show 6 days with 2-inch-plus hail within 10 miles from 2005 through 2024.
  • Class 4 products are not all equal. IBHS publishes free hail ratings for specific shingle products. Check yours before you sign.
  • TDI says each insurer sets its own impact-resistant discount and paperwork rules. There is no single Texas percentage.
  • Keep the packaging label and a completed TDI form PC068 (or your insurer's form), and send a copy to your insurer.
  • Texas law limits an HOA's ability to block hail-resistant shingles that match the neighborhood look.

What "impact-resistant" means (and does not)

Most residential marketing points to UL 2218. According to a May 2020 article in IIBEC's Interface journal by Haag Research & Testing, Underwriters Laboratories developed UL 2218 in 1996. Steel balls are dropped onto roofing samples from heights chosen to match the kinetic energy of falling hailstones. Products are classed 1 through 4, and Class 4 is the highest class.

UL 2218 classSteel ball diameterDrop heightImpact energy
Class 11¼ in12 ft3.53 ft-lbf
Class 21½ in15 ft7.35 ft-lbf
Class 31¾ in17 ft13.56 ft-lbf
Class 42 in20 ft23.71 ft-lbf

The same article explains how the test works. The balls are aimed at the most vulnerable spots, such as corners, edges, and unsupported areas, and each spot is hit twice within half an inch. To pass, the sample can show no tears, fractures, or cracks through the product when viewed under 5X magnification. Crushed granules and dents are allowed, because the test treats them as cosmetic.

A second standard, ANSI FM 4473 from Factory Mutual, uses propelled ice balls instead of steel balls, with classes that mirror UL 2218. The article also notes that rigid products like tile or slate often cannot pass UL 2218 even though they may perform better in real hail. So the class rating applies to the test, not to every storm.

Important limits:

  • The test is a standardized lab impact, not a replay of every Collin County storm.
  • Class 4 is not a force field. After severe hail, Class 4 roofs are still inspected and sometimes replaced.
  • Leaks can still start at flashings, ridges, and penetrations even when the field shingles are Class 4.

Think of an impact rating as risk reduction, not immunity.

What the Class 4 test does not check

The Haag Research & Testing study in that article tested five impact-resistant shingles: four labeled Class 4 and one Class 3. After impact, the researchers removed the asphalt with a solvent to look at the reinforcing mat underneath. All five had fractured reinforcement. Looking only at the surface, two of the shingles showed fractures and three showed only dents.

The authors wrote that two of the five performed as well as their product literature stated, "but only because the pass/fail criteria" of UL 2218 do not require examining the reinforcement this way. In their words, reinforced backing could hide fractures, and hail dents in asphalt shingles "typically indicate fractures or substantial strains."

Five shingles is a small sample, and it does not mean Class 4 is worthless. It does mean "it only dented" is not proof that a roof was unharmed. If a big storm hits, have the roof looked at. Our roof inspection page explains how to request one.

Celina hail vs the 2-inch test ball

The Class 4 test ball is 2 inches across. NOAA Storm Prediction Center reports show that hail at least that big has fallen near every town we serve. The table counts separate days with at least one report within 10 miles of each town's center from 2005–2024. A report means someone measured hail in the area. It does not mean every roof was hit.

TownDays with 1-inch+ hailDays with 2-inch+ hailLargest report
Celina 34 6 3" on April 6, 2018
Prosper 49 16 4.5" on March 24, 2019
Anna 33 2 2" on May 29, 2016
Melissa 46 7 2.75" on April 21, 2017
Princeton 39 10 2.75" on April 21, 2017

Celina's largest nearby report was 3" (teacup-size) hail on April 6, 2018, about a mile from the town center. That is bigger than the 2-inch ball used in the Class 4 test.

IBHS has the same concern. Its 2025 Research Agenda says its shingle test covers 1.5-inch and 2-inch hail, but many areas east of the Rocky Mountains often get bigger hail. It cites a 2017 study by Allen et al. that puts the return period for 4-inch hail at about 20 years in the traditional Tornado Alley region, including the northern half of Texas. IBHS also reports that its 2022 and 2023 lab testing "revealed significant damage to asphalt shingles even with just 2.5-inch impacts."

The takeaway: an impact-resistant roof can lower risk from the common 1- to 2-inch storms, but it cannot promise to survive the largest North Texas hail. For year-by-year storm data, see our Celina hail history. If you are dealing with damage now, start with our storm & hail damage page.

IBHS hail ratings: checking the specific product

Because UL 2218 is pass/fail, IBHS built its own test. According to its November 2025 news release, the fourth edition of its ratings covers 24 products, which IBHS says represent about 95% of impact-resistant shingles sold each year. Key points from the release:

  • IBHS buys the shingles from retail sources, the same way a homeowner or roofer would.
  • Since 2019 it has used lab-made hailstones that it calls "more realistic than traditional steel balls."
  • Products are scored on three kinds of damage: dents, tears, and granule loss. The 2025 edition added a numerical score.
  • Most products rated Good, and none rated Excellent.
  • IBHS's Anne Cope: "If a product rates Marginal or Poor, we do not recommend using it in areas that experience hail."

The full list is free at ibhs.org/ImpactRatings. IBHS states there that not all impact-resistant shingles perform the same, and suggests asking your roofer. Before you sign a bid, look up the exact product line on the list.

FORTIFIED Roof and the Hail Supplement

IBHS also runs the FORTIFIED program. Its October 2025 product advisory says a Hail Supplement can be added to a FORTIFIED High Wind or Hurricane designation when the requirements are met and documented. With asphalt shingles, the shingles must be rated "Excellent" or "Good" on the IBHS ratings current when the roof is installed. Roofs permitted or installed on or after November 1, 2025 must meet the updated ratings. If FORTIFIED interests you, ask whether the roofer is set up to do it before you sign. See fortifiedhome.org for the program details.

Class 4 vs "upgrade package" language on bids

A proposal might list:

  • A specific manufacturer + product line + color + UL 2218 Class 4
  • Or a vague "impact upgrade" with no product sheet

Insist on the named product. Class ratings attach to tested products, not to a contractor's adjective. TDI says each insurer decides what product labeling it requires, and a vague "upgrade" has no label to show. Ask for the manufacturer's product data sheet and keep it with your HOA approval and warranty paperwork.

Texas insurance credits: what TDI actually says

Texas insurers have offered premium discounts for Class 4 UL 2218 products since 1998, according to the IIBEC article. TDI's current page on products qualifying for impact-resistant roofing credits sets out how it works today:

  • Roofing materials must be tested by a lab to a recognized standard and are classed 1 to 4. Class 4 receives the highest premium credit.
  • The discount amount varies by insurance company.
  • Each insurer decides which test criteria it accepts, how products must be labeled, and what paperwork it needs.
  • TDI does not endorse any roofing material.

The same page explains the rules for the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA): UL 2218 testing, labels showing the lab, class, manufacturer, year made, and brand, and form PC068 completed by the contractor. Per TWIA's overview, it provides wind and hail coverage in designated parts of the Texas seacoast territory, so it does not cover inland Collin County. Still, its rules show the kind of proof a private insurer may ask for.

TDI form PC068 (Roofing Installation Certificate)

Form PC068 is a one-page certificate. It says that "some insurance companies may offer an insurance premium discount" for a qualifying roof, and that the form is not a warranty. The roofing company fills in:

  • The roofing company's name and the property address
  • The roof covering's manufacturer, brand name, and year manufactured
  • The installation date
  • Whether the packaging was labeled with the UL 2218 class, manufacturer, date, and brand, and whether a label from the packaging was given to the owner
  • A certification that the roof covering was installed to the manufacturer's specifications, with its UL 2218 class (1 to 4)

The form tells the owner to keep the original and send a copy to the insurance company. TDI says other insurers may use PC068 or their own form, so ask which one yours wants before the crew starts. Ask the roofer to save a packaging label for you, because once the bundles are on the roof and the wrappers are gone, the label is hard to get back.

Coverage terms to check at the same time

TDI's "Insurance and your roof" guide adds points that matter when you replace a roof. Some policies pay replacement cost and others pay actual cash value, which is less for an older or worn roof. As roofs age, some companies switch to actual cash value, and your company should tell you when it changes your coverage. TDI also says an insurer inspects the roof when you apply and may charge more or refuse coverage based on what it sees. And it suggests materials less likely to be damaged by wind, hail, or fire, noting that "your insurance company might give you a discount for using them."

Questions to ask your agent

  1. Do you offer an impact-resistant roof credit on my policy?
  2. Which test standards and classes qualify: UL 2218, FM 4473, Class 3 or only Class 4?
  3. Do you need form PC068, your own form, a packaging label, or an inspection?
  4. Is the credit a percentage or a flat amount, and which part of the premium does it apply to?
  5. Does a new roof change my coverage from actual cash value back to replacement cost?
  6. Is my wind and hail deductible different from my other deductible?
  7. Can a future claim or roof inspection change or remove the credit?

Write down the answers with the date and the agent's name. Do not rely on a neighbor's carrier rules for your policy.

What we will not do in this article

We will not quote a "typical Texas discount" percentage. TDI says the amount varies by company, and a made-up number would mislead Celina readers.

Deductibles still drive many decisions

Even with a premium credit, a percentage wind/hail deductible on a higher-value Celina home can make small post-hail repairs a cash decision. TDI suggests asking whether your wind and hail deductible differs from your other deductible, because if it does, you might pay more out of pocket after a storm. Impact-resistant products may reduce how often or how badly a roof is damaged. They do not change your deductible.

Install quality: where Class 4 wins or loses

PC068 asks the roofer to certify that the roof was installed to the manufacturer's specifications, which shows how much rides on the install. Common failure points on otherwise good shingles:

  • Incorrect nail placement or under- or over-driven fasteners
  • Skipped starter courses
  • Ridge cap products that are not the manufacturer's compatible accessory
  • Poor valley metal and step flashing
  • Unbalanced attic intake and exhaust (heat aging)

If you are paying for Class 4, ask how fastening and accessories will be handled and documented, and how the workmanship warranty is written. For what a full replacement involves, see roof replacement in Celina.

HOA rules: what Texas law says

Celina and Prosper HOAs often care more about color and profile than impact class. Texas law gives homeowners some protection here. Texas Property Code § 202.011, added in 2011, says a property owners' association may not prohibit or restrict an owner who is otherwise allowed to install shingles from installing shingles designed primarily to be wind and hail resistant (or to improve heating and cooling efficiency, or to generate solar power), as long as, once installed, they:

  • resemble the shingles used or allowed in the subdivision,
  • are more durable than, and of equal or better quality than, those shingles, and
  • match the look of the surrounding properties.

That does not mean you can skip the HOA. The look still has to match, and your architectural review process still applies. Before ordering:

  • Submit the exact product and color name for approval.
  • Confirm any ridge vent visibility rules.
  • Keep approval letters with your home records for a future buyer.

This is general information, not legal advice. Our Celina HOA roofing guide covers the approval process in more detail. Buyers and inspectors may ask what product is on the roof, and a documented install makes that conversation easier than "we think it's impact-rated."

Class 4 asphalt vs metal and other materials

Metal, tile, and other materials handle hail differently, and the IIBEC article notes that rigid products may not fit the UL 2218 test at all. Insurers may also treat cosmetic damage to metal differently depending on the policy, so ask your agent. Neither option automatically wins every hail scenario. Compare materials in our shingle vs metal guide and the roofing materials guide (underlayment, flashing and fasteners), and see budget drivers in our roof replacement cost guide.

Buying strategy: planned replacement vs mid-claim

On a planned timeline

  1. Pick HOA-approved Class 4 candidates and look each one up on the IBHS ratings.
  2. Ask your insurer which form and labels it needs before installation.
  3. Confirm who registers the manufacturer warranty, and when.
  4. Ask the roofer to save a packaging label and complete PC068 or your insurer's form.
  5. Photograph completed slopes and flashings.
  6. Send the proof packet to your agent and check whether any credit appears at renewal.

In the middle of a claim

  • Do not assume the carrier will pay for a Class 4 upgrade. Ask your insurer or agent in writing.
  • Upgrades may be out of pocket or partly covered depending on the policy and settlement.
  • Get upgrade pricing as a clear written change order, not a verbal blur.

TDI's guide also notes that an insurer won't pay for a new roof just because it is old or worn out. For deadlines, see our Texas roof claim deadlines guide.

Manufacturer warranties vs marketing years

Long warranty banners sell shingles. PC068 itself states that it is not a warranty, so read the actual warranty terms separately:

  • What voids coverage (wrong fasteners, improper ventilation, unapproved alterations)
  • Transferability if you sell the home
  • Any wind-rating conditions tied to specific installation methods
  • Whether hail is covered at all, and how warranty service differs from an insurance claim

More detail is in our Texas roofing warranties guide.

Red flags in "insurance discount" sales pitches

  • Guarantees a specific premium savings without seeing your policy. TDI says the amount varies by company.
  • Ties the "discount" to signing claim or assignment paperwork the same afternoon
  • Cannot name the product line or its UL 2218 class
  • Won't fill out PC068 or your insurer's form, or can't give you a packaging label
  • Claims Class 4 means you will never need another claim

For more on vetting any roofer, read how to hire a roofer in Celina.

A practical decision frame

SituationLean toward
Long hold, hail-exposed slopes, HOA allows architectural lookA named Class 4 product rated Good on the IBHS list, plus strong ventilation
Custom elevation, HOA-approved metalMetal conversation (separate tradeoffs)
Short hold, tight budget, roof otherwise soundRepair if damage is local; run the math before upgrading
Mid-claim upgrade curiosityWritten upgrade price + agent confirmation on coverage

Heat still matters with impact products

Hail resistance does not pause thermal aging. Dark shingles over a poorly ventilated attic still get hot. When you invest in Class 4:

  • Require a ventilation plan in the same proposal. See our attic ventilation guide.
  • Keep trees trimmed. TDI's roof checklist also says to remove limbs hanging over or near the roof and keep gutters clean.

A documentation packet for your agent (after install)

  1. Completed TDI form PC068 or your insurer's own form (keep the original, send a copy)
  2. The packaging label showing the UL 2218 class, manufacturer, date, and brand
  3. Final invoice with the product line item
  4. Manufacturer product sheet showing the UL 2218 class
  5. A printout of the product's IBHS rating, if it is listed
  6. Dated overview photos of each slope
  7. Warranty registration confirmation
  8. City permit and final inspection record, if one was issued
  9. A short cover note: install date, address, and a request to confirm any impact credit on your policy

Follow up at renewal if you expected a credit and do not see it.

Patchwork roofs

If your roof is already a mix of products and dates from earlier storm repairs, impact documentation gets complicated for both insurance and resale. PC068 asks for one manufacturer, brand, and install date, so ask whether a full tear-off is needed for a clean, whole-roof record your agent will recognize.

Frequently asked questions

What does Class 4 mean on a shingle?

It is the highest class in UL 2218, a lab test that drops steel balls on roofing samples. Per a 2020 IIBEC Interface article by Haag Research & Testing, Class 4 uses a 2-inch ball dropped 20 feet. To pass, the sample can show no tears, fractures, or cracks through the product under 5X magnification, while dents and crushed granules are treated as cosmetic.

Is there a set Texas discount for Class 4 shingles?

No set amount. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) says the discount amount varies by insurance company, and each company decides which test criteria, labeling, and paperwork it accepts. TDI says Class 4 receives the highest premium credit. Ask your own agent what your policy offers.

What is TDI form PC068?

PC068 is TDI's Roofing Installation Certificate. The roofing company fills in the product manufacturer, brand, year manufactured, install date, and UL 2218 class, and certifies the roof was installed to the manufacturer's specifications. The form says to keep the original and send a copy to your insurance company. TDI says some insurers use PC068 and others use their own form.

Do all Class 4 shingles hold up the same in hail?

No. IBHS says not all impact-resistant shingles perform the same. Its 2025 ratings tested 24 products bought at retail using lab-made hailstones and scored them on dents, tears, and granule loss. Most rated Good and none rated Excellent. IBHS says it does not recommend products rated Marginal or Poor in areas that get hail.

Can hail bigger than 2 inches still damage a Class 4 roof?

Yes, it can. The Class 4 test ball is 2 inches. IBHS reports that its 2022 and 2023 lab testing found significant damage to asphalt shingles even with 2.5-inch impacts. NOAA reports show hail of 2 inches or larger within 10 miles of Celina on 6 days from 2005 through 2024.

Can my HOA stop me from installing impact-resistant shingles?

Texas Property Code section 202.011 says a property owners' association may not prohibit or restrict shingles designed primarily to be wind and hail resistant, if when installed they resemble the shingles used or allowed in the subdivision, are more durable and of equal or better quality, and match the look of the surrounding properties. Submit the exact product and color to your HOA anyway. This is not legal advice.

Do Class 4 shingles lower my wind and hail deductible?

No. A deductible is a policy term. TDI suggests asking your agent whether your wind and hail deductible is different from the deductible for other damage. A tougher roof may affect how often it is damaged, and some insurers may offer a premium discount, but neither changes the deductible on your policy.

Will insurance pay to upgrade my roof to Class 4 after a claim?

Do not assume it will. Coverage and settlement terms depend on your policy, so ask your insurer or agent in writing before you choose an upgrade. Get the upgrade price from the roofer as a separate written line item.

Does Celina Roof Pros handle my insurance discount or claim?

No. Celina Roof Pros is a free referral service that sends your quote request to one local roofer. We are not a roofing contractor or an insurer, and we never help with insurance claims or speak to adjusters. The roofer who installs your roof provides the product and installation paperwork, and any policy change is between you and your agent.

Bottom line

Impact-resistant (often Class 4) shingles are a reasonable upgrade to consider for many Celina replacements because hail is a real risk here. They are not hail-proof, the Class 4 test stops at a 2-inch ball, and Texas insurance credits are set by each insurer. Pick a named product, check its IBHS rating, get it installed to the manufacturer's specs, and keep PC068 and the label with your policy file.

Celina Roof Pros is a free referral service that sends your quote request to one local roofer. We are not a roofing contractor or your insurer, we do not promise underwriting outcomes, and we never help with insurance claims or speak to adjusters. When you want Class 4 options priced for your home, see roof replacement, roof repair, or storm and hail damage. Request a free quote. Serving Celina, Melissa, Anna, Princeton, and Prosper.

Sources

← All resources · Celina hail history · Replacement cost guide · Request a quote

Ready for a clear roofing plan?

Tell us about your roof in Celina or nearby. One local roofer calls you to inspect the roof, document conditions, and explain options. One call, no spam calls, and your info is never sold or shared.